This was excellent. I have to assume it’s more thorough and comprehensive thinking than most teams put into their hiring processes.
There’s probably some selection bias in that team’s hiring new coordinators may have known their units weren’t that good, but the numbers are still pretty stark.
I wonder what the right way to integrate a new play caller is — because the McDermott example shows that maybe some of these hires are good, they’re just early.
Thanks for reading! That’s a great question about the right environment. I’m not 100% sure since every situation, roster, and team dynamic is so different. But at a high level, I think the McDermott example shows the benefit of time and support from veteran coaches with past success not to mention talent acquisition from the front office. McDermott had support from an experienced defensive coach in Ron Rivera, space to grow, and elite talent to work with.
Even Doug Pederson, as a new playcaller in 2016 had ex-offensive coordinators on his staff along with coaches like Duce Staley and Jeff Stoutland who were familiar with the team culture, dynamics, and players from Chip Kelly’s tenure. Not to mention Howie Roseman acquiring premium talent.
If we look the factors of time, veteran coach support, talent, and some consistency with the last coaching staff, I think external first-time coordinator hires need at least 3 of the 4. Mannion has talent (albeit injuries) and some holdover from the last staff, but lacks support from successful veteran offensive coaches and time. Parker just got veteran support who took his job and pretty much lacks everything else (Cowboys only held onto one coach from last year’s defensive staff).
This was excellent. I have to assume it’s more thorough and comprehensive thinking than most teams put into their hiring processes.
There’s probably some selection bias in that team’s hiring new coordinators may have known their units weren’t that good, but the numbers are still pretty stark.
I wonder what the right way to integrate a new play caller is — because the McDermott example shows that maybe some of these hires are good, they’re just early.
Thanks for reading! That’s a great question about the right environment. I’m not 100% sure since every situation, roster, and team dynamic is so different. But at a high level, I think the McDermott example shows the benefit of time and support from veteran coaches with past success not to mention talent acquisition from the front office. McDermott had support from an experienced defensive coach in Ron Rivera, space to grow, and elite talent to work with.
Even Doug Pederson, as a new playcaller in 2016 had ex-offensive coordinators on his staff along with coaches like Duce Staley and Jeff Stoutland who were familiar with the team culture, dynamics, and players from Chip Kelly’s tenure. Not to mention Howie Roseman acquiring premium talent.
If we look the factors of time, veteran coach support, talent, and some consistency with the last coaching staff, I think external first-time coordinator hires need at least 3 of the 4. Mannion has talent (albeit injuries) and some holdover from the last staff, but lacks support from successful veteran offensive coaches and time. Parker just got veteran support who took his job and pretty much lacks everything else (Cowboys only held onto one coach from last year’s defensive staff).
But it’s a good question! What do you think?